Monday, August 21, 2006

Book review - Firebird

by Kathy Tyers. 1999. Bethany House.

Firebird is a fast-paced space opera which was originally published in the mainstream SF market, and then rewritten for an evangelical audience. It centers around two characters: strong-willed Firebird Angelo, and the telepathic Brennen Caldwell.

Born into the ruling family of Netaia, Firebird is wealthy and educated, but she knows her life will not be long. The Netaian nobility eliminates excess heirs once they fall past a certain point in the succession, and Firebird has fallen to the point of no return. Thus she eschews romance and long-term plans, training as a fighter pilot and hoping to die in a blaze of glory. Her class lives in opulent luxury, repressing the common people through a state religion, a culture of obedience and brute force. Their vaguely Confucian religion preaches conformity and worships a set of deified attributes, such as Strength, Knowledge, and Excellence. Their culture is xenophobic, holding itself proudly aloof from the Federacy, an interstellar alliance which upholds human rights and freedoms.

When Netaia begins a war of expansion on nearby Veroh, Firebird eagerly goes off, seeking a glorious death. But Veroh is a Federacy protectorate and she soon finds herself a prisoner, captured and interrogated by Brennen, a Sentinel.

Descended from a nearly extinct people who genetically altered themselves to gain uncanny powers, the Sentinels who live in the Federacy follow a strict code of conduct which regulates use of their telepathic and telekinetic abilities. They also wield a special weapon - the crystace is a simple hilt from which, upon activation, emerges a long crystal blade that can deflect laser blasts and cut practically anything. (Sounds like the Jedi, huh?)

Ever since the Sentinel’s ancestors misused their powers and died in a catastrophic civil war, a small, exiled remnant has sought to atone by using their powers for good and remaining faithful to their religion. They worship one God, whom they hope one day will send a Messiah. They’re essentially Jews.

But not quite. These people have two testaments, and a Trinitarian concept of God. Nor do they seem to sacrifice animals. Their preoccupations and expectations are more Christian than Jewish. As might be expected, their emphases are evangelical. For example, only two aspects of their hoped-for Messiah are mentioned in this volume: he will perform an act of sin-cleansing substitionary atonement; and after he comes his people will again be allowed to proselytize. So perhaps it would be correct to say that the Sentinels are Jedi Jews for Jesus!

Does all this sound derivative? You bet. We’ve got the Star Trek Federation battling World War II Japan while Jewish Jedi rush about performing mind melds. But Tyers manages to spin it into an entertaining space opera. She accomplishes this by providing plenty of action, and by focusing on strong characters. Firebird is daring, driven and self-destructive. Brennen is powerful, conscientious and intense, and it’s not surprising that a romance soon sparks between them.

I felt that Tyers created so much excitement and tension with the military exploits of the first half of the story that the second half seemed rather tame and predictable. Firebird and Brennen go on to engage in dangerous James Bond-style adventures, but the shift in scale creates the impression we’ve switched genres, from military SF to romantic thriller. Much of the political intrigue will only be interesting if you go on to read the other sections of the trilogy, and I suspect Tyers reworked her books to flow best when read as one epic tale.

The spiritual elements work fairly well. Firebird rejects the graceless tradition she was raised in, but she is not immediately comfortable with Brennen’s unfamiliar religion. She struggles with her pride and selfishness while trying to understand his faith. I was particularly moved by her vision of God as an almighty singer, creating and conducting the music of the galaxies. It fits nicely with Firebird’s talent as a harpist, and the musically themed chapter headings.

Firebird is a worthy addition to the field of Christian SF, though it’s best read along with its sequels.

3.5 out of 5

7 comments:

Rebecca said...

JEDI JEWS FOR JESUS!!!!

Oh, now I want to read it just for the joy of squirting milk out of my nose. (But I have a five year old for that pleasure.)

3.5, Elliot. You're not winning me over. But you are entertaining. excellent synopsis and review.

Rebecca LuElla Miller said...

I agree with Rebecca. You did a very nice summation--not an easy thing to do, I've discovered. I thought Tyers did an excellent job with the religious elements as well.

As far as being deriviative, I just haven't read any SF at all (well, C. S. Lewis and that was ages ago) so it all felt fresh to me.

Becky

Elliot said...

:-) Thanks!

Rebecca G.: Well, I give the second book in the trilogy 4 out of 5. And I'm not quite the target market for this - I think women who attend evangelical churches would enjoy it the most, followed by evangelical men. The mark is pretty subjective.

Becky: I think the problem might be that I've read *too much* science fiction, and I have a good memory for stories, so I can't help picking out common themes and recycled ideas.

Elliot said...

PS: If, as I've read on someone else's blog, Firebird started it's life as Star Wars fan fiction, it's not at all surprising that there's Star Wars concepts to be found there. Tyers does a good job of taking those elements and making the story her own.

Diedre said...

I would agree with your review as well. It's not stunningly awesome, but it is definitely good enough to read. I keep them on my shelf as comfort/sick reading, now that I've read them a few times. And yes, the Great Singer is an awesome name for God!

Clemens said...

The Great Singer?
Aslan.

Moriel said...

I must have read this back during the original blog-tour thing--got linked to it from lady_firebird, probably, a Kathy Tyers yahoogroup I mostly lurk on--and the "Jedi Jews for Jesus" phrase kind of stuck in my head. So when I wrote a review of the Firebird books for my book-review blog, I linked to this article. (Probably also going to add you to my blogroll there, if that's cool with you.) Just thought you might like to know.